BERLIN, Germany — Germany is considering restrictions that could push Huawei and ZTE much further out of its mobile networks, challenging a compromise intended to reconcile national security with the cost of replacing Chinese equipment. The Interior Ministry told the business newspaper Handelsblatt that the changed security environment required a reassessment of dependencies in critical infrastructure.
The immediate development is a proposed regulatory change, rather than an enacted blanket ban. Germany submitted its revised telecommunications security catalogue to the European Commission on September 29; the notification lists a standstill period ending December 30.
Beyond the Network Core
Under Germany’s existing agreements, Deutsche Telekom, Vodafone and Telefónica must stop using critical Huawei and ZTE components in their 5G core networks by the end of 2026. By the end of 2029, they must also replace critical functions in Chinese-supplied network management systems serving their access and transport networks. Those obligations do not amount to wholesale replacement of every Chinese-made base station.
The proposed catalogue would broaden the security perimeter by classifying all functions of 5G base stations as critical. The Federal Network Agency argues that evolving network architectures give these stations important security and control responsibilities, and that foreign interference could cause disruption across regions. Such a classification could provide the basis for further supplier restrictions.
The commercial consequences could be extensive. Equipment is often supplied as integrated systems, making individual components difficult to replace independently. European suppliers Ericsson and Nokia, alongside South Korea’s Samsung, offer alternatives; the difficulty lies in migrating existing networks, rather than any inherent requirement for Chinese technology.
Operators Challenge the Case
Industry opposition has sharpened. On November 5, Deutsche Telekom’s chief executive, Tim Höttges, said the company had identified no security breach or security problem involving its Chinese partners. He maintained that Telekom was implementing its existing agreement with the government. His comments represent the operator’s assessment, not an independent guarantee against future threats.
Telekom has also warned that a hurried replacement program would absorb engineers and investment needed for network expansion, potentially weakening service quality. Huawei, meanwhile, told Golem that it had submitted technical and legal assessments challenging the proposed classification of base stations.
The regulator’s consultation record reveals a divided industry: all participating operators opposed the broader classification as disproportionate, while three of four manufacturers supported it. Operators argued that the failure of an individual base station would have a local impact; the agency maintained that newer architectures and potential coordinated interference justified wider precautions.
Europe Debates the Cost of Separation
Germany’s dispute sits within a broader European effort to reduce exposure to suppliers considered high risk. The European Commission’s proposed revision of the Cybersecurity Act would make such reductions mandatory in mobile networks, treating foreign influence and supplier dependence as security concerns alongside technical vulnerabilities.
The timetable remains contested. Reuters reported in September that EU governments had proposed replacing the Commission’s fixed 36-month phase-out with deadlines reflecting risk, equipment lifecycles and available alternatives. Connect Europe, an operators’ association, estimates replacement costs of up to €40 billion across the sector—a Europe-wide industry estimate.
Beijing has opposed the European approach. Responding to the industry’s objections on September 16, Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun described discriminatory restrictions as protectionist and warned that they would damage Europe’s investment appeal.
Taken together, these positions expose two competing definitions of resilience: reducing dependence on suppliers vulnerable to foreign-state pressure, and preserving reliable service during a costly transition. Germany’s next decision will test whether it can advance both goals with a credible timetable—and a clear account of who pays.
Photo: AI Generated